25 Comments
User's avatar
Colin Brabazon's avatar

One of the best. I never read a book or a story by Jane Gardam that I didn’t love. Your piece does her much justice. May she be read, indeed.

Expand full comment
Tandy's avatar

Can’t recall how I encountered Jane – it may have been through you. The Old Filth trilogy is one of my favorite reading experiences of the last decade. Thank you for this.

Expand full comment
Caroline's avatar

How very sad! I remember being baffled - in a good way - by The Summer After The Funeral as a teenager, and then experiencing the same disorientating universe in The Queen of the Tambourine. Much later I came to Old Filth, which is indeed a work of genius. RIP.

Expand full comment
Henry Oliver's avatar

So sad. I feel quite upset

Expand full comment
Caroline's avatar

We need a Persephone Books for those second half of the twentieth century women who are now so unfashionable - Gardam, Brookner, Spark, Thomas Ellis, Drabble, even Murdoch.

Expand full comment
Henry Oliver's avatar

They are all in print through. What we need is more advocacy!

Expand full comment
Caroline's avatar

I stand corrected - you are right!

Expand full comment
Henry Oliver's avatar

Well you were right in the sense that Persephone has been a great advocate for their authors, giving them a brand etc

Expand full comment
Deborah Vass's avatar

They are all writers that I love and so little mentioned now.

Expand full comment
Claire's avatar

RIP indeed. I must now read some that I've missed.

Expand full comment
Allie's avatar

I lived in the same small street as Jane Gardam and her husband for a few years, and perhaps it was typical of such a non-showy, sensitive author that many neighbours didn't know who she was, and those who did never made a fuss. A brilliant writer.

Expand full comment
Henry Oliver's avatar

What a lovely story. Did you know her?

Expand full comment
Allie's avatar

On first name terms only, to chat with if we bumped into each other. My two small children were inevitably in tow, and I recall her husband's enjoying a chat with them in particular. I recognised her from the outset but never let on; her natural reticence seemed not to invite it.

Expand full comment
Jack Bentz SJ's avatar

Yes, I walk into any book store and look to the fiction G to see if there is one I have not yet read. And she is the only thing that makes me linger in second hand book shops. RIP

Expand full comment
Peter Brooke Turner's avatar

Sad to hear she died - very much loved the Old Filth trilogy.

Expand full comment
Lucy Seton-Watson's avatar

This is awful (that she's died). For me she's our leading current novelist. Wonderful treatment of the absurd, savage and underneath that, deeply understanding. Try Faith Fox and Flight of the Maidens. And Bilgewater and A Long Way from Verona are brilliant for the terrifyingness of the world when young.

Oh dear, how sad.

Expand full comment
Deborah Vass's avatar

I hadn't heard of her death, and I am so sad to hear of it. She was such a remarkable writer and I loved her books dearly, especially "Bilgewater". Thank you for such a beautiful and fitting tribute.

Expand full comment
David44's avatar

So sorry to hear that she died. I only know the Old Filth trilogy (surely you should say sequelS, not "sequel"?), but I constantly recommend them to people - they are such unexpected works, not least because only when one reads the second and third books is one aware of the unexplained gaps in the narrative of the first, and so there is a sense of constantly expanding horizons, and the richness of the characters as each is seen from a new perspective. Thank you for the other recommendations of her books - I'll look forward to trying them!

Expand full comment
Henry Oliver's avatar

I admire the second book much more than the third

Expand full comment
Lucy Seton-Watson's avatar

Yes, I didn't like the third. It was as if she wasn't really concentrating. Really not good.

Expand full comment
David44's avatar

That's interesting - that wasn't my own reaction. I found the way the background of Veneering was explored in the third book so revealing, explaining so much about his relationship with Feathers and Betty from the first and the second - how Veneering and Feathers are both "exotic" self-created characters, but with social class separating them, and how that leads into the kind of wary antagonism that defined their interactions in the earlier books. It seemed to me to round off the story so effectively.

I would agree that the third book, of the three, is the one that stands up least well as a novel in its own right - it plays off the other two much more - but surely no one reads it as a novel in its own right. But I would be interested to know why you are more negative about it.

Expand full comment
John's avatar

Such a wonderful author. Rest in peace.

Expand full comment
Henry Oliver's avatar

So so good

Expand full comment
Richard LeComte's avatar

I loved Old Filth. It takes off in all sorts of remarkable directions in a relatively short novel. For example, the bananas.

Expand full comment
Henry Oliver's avatar

Yes she gets so much in

Expand full comment