Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Roberts's avatar

Bad reviews are unpopular, but essential. Thanks for this section.

Expand full comment
June Girvin's avatar

Thank you for this. Wifedom is sitting on my 'to-read' pile so I find your comments really interesting. I was persuaded by a very positive review by Caroline Criado Perez, but now I'm intrigued to see how I feel about it. This business of inserting yourself in to books about other people is becoming more popular I think, and more frustrating. I'm a keen gardener and was persuaded by reviews to buy a book called 'Why Women Grow' by Alice Vincent. I was expecting it to be about women gardeners/growers, a combination of history, biography, achievement, a celebration of women who grow. It wasn't. it was mostly about the author's relationship, her shall I, shan't I have a baby self-talk, and a few discussions with a small number of self-selected women who did a bit of gardening. I felt similarly to you in describing Wifedom. A waste of time and money, reading about someone's thirty-something angst.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts