7 Comments

I just finished Silas Marner, now one of my favorite books. I searched Common Reader to see if you’d written anything on it. Of course you had, and brilliantly as usual. I felt, but hadn’t understood the fairy tale tropes. Thanks for explaining!

Also love your line, “psychology is real, even if magic isn’t.” I found myself in awe many times at how real the characters felt. Their psychology seemed so clear and beautifully expressed. The pub scene felt so accurate I could have sworn I’d been there, but with extra powers of perception provided by Eliot. Like when I go somewhere with my wife and she later recounts an exchange I was present for with a psychological subtext I had been oblivious to.

Can’t wait to read more Eliot now.

Expand full comment

My first! I keep seeing you and others talk about Middlemarch, so I was thinking I’d tackle that soon.

Expand full comment

It’s extraordinary

Expand full comment

your first? Mill on Floss and Middlemarch and Adam Bede are all excellent

Expand full comment

Do you have a favorite Eliot biography?

Expand full comment

I started a commeht, and am not sure where it went! Now I saw, then I didn't!

Anyway, Henry, thanks for this illuminating insight about the fairy tale/mystical tropes and the clear-eyed realism.

I'm continually amazed by the exquisite descriptions of people, places, and events in Eliot.

As you point out, she is a celebrator of the ordinary and takes pains to draw out the implications of our subtle moral choices.

Thank you!!! (I must now re-read this novel!)

Expand full comment

Eliot always improves on rereading!

Expand full comment