9 Comments
User's avatar
Max Davies's avatar

I see for Nature no defeat

In one tree’s overthrow

Or for myself in my retreat

For yet another blow.

Why is the line "For yet another blow" and not "From yet another blow"?

Henry Oliver's avatar

He retreated in order to make another blow — ie the retreat was not for escape but for respite before another blow (chop) at the tree

June Girvin's avatar

A great piece. Thank you.

Henry Oliver's avatar

glad you liked it! I might write more about him...

Josh Holly's avatar

Thanks for writing about Into My Own. I wasn't familiar with it.

Josh Holly's avatar

Please do write more about him! He strikes a nerve for sure. That last stanza in In The Winter Woods Alone equates the felled tree in Nature with the back swing of the axe. Maybe? I see that the retreat is also his trudge back home through the snowy woods. But I think of our month of Darwin... and I remember SJ Gould using Frost in some of his writing and lectures. This can't be coincidence. Frost seems often to play with ideas that touch the point where Nature and thought overlap. Design, for instance, is Darwinian and paradoxical. Maybe when the axe is in the back swing considerations go out the window. Then comes the next blow.

John's avatar

He was, remarkably considering my young age and lack of life experience at the time, the first American poet I read avidly. Thank you.

Henry Oliver's avatar

A very good place to start!

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 29, 2024
Comment deleted
Henry Oliver's avatar

Thank you! I feel like I still have more to say too