Bumbition and late bloomers
Noah Smith has identified a trait of a certain type of successful person in Silicon Valley that he calls “bumbition”. It’s a great piece.
Bumbition, however, defies placement on the ambitious/bum spectrum. It exhibits elements of both. For a significant portion of their life, a bumbitious person doesn’t strive hard, or apply themselves to definite goals…until a clear and compelling opportunity presents itself. When that opportunity to do something really interesting or impactful does come up, the bumbitious person is quick to recognize it, and works very hard to exploit it.
Some of the examples Noah gives of people like this outside tech include Ulysses S. Grant and Charles Darwin. He calls them “people who looked lackadaisical until they suddenly rose to greatness.” Yes indeed. They are two archetypal late bloomers!
Noah’s account of bumbition is almost exactly how I described the way late bloomers achieve success in Second Act. When I researched the book, I paid a lot of attention to tech talent. I even interviewed Noah. So maybe it isn’t a surprise that our ideas overlap. But I think the fact that he has identified this pattern based on his immersion in the tech world is a sign that it’s the right one.
At the end of my research, I found a paper that studied the the careers of scientists, film directors and artists. I was struck with how similar its finding were to my own (less empirical) ideas. The study looked at what caused a hot streak in someone’s career—those exceptional periods of a decade or so when talented people cram in a huge amount of activity and achievement.
What conditions have to be present for a hot streak to occur? The study found that before the hot streak begins there is an exploration phase, when new ideas are gathered, which is followed by a period of exploitation, when those new ideas are turned into original and impactful work.
This is similar to the explore/exploit dynamic, an idea from computer science, which says that to make the best decisions we should find the correct balance between gathering information (exploring our options) and making the most of what we know (exploiting that information). To make the best decisions, we need to balance exploration and exploitation.
What the research on artists, filmmakers, and scientists found was not that either exploration or exploitation alone was critical to a hot streak: it was the transition from explore to exploit that mattered. Exploring before exploiting means you can discover the most productive ideas and expand your creative possibilities. What matters is the switch.
Too much exploration can be risky: you end up as a dabbler, a dilettante. Too much exploitation can be boring: you don’t discover enough new information to do interesting, original work. To have a hot streak, a burst of your best work, you need to switch from explore to exploit. Importantly, these findings were robust whether the hot streak came early in a career or late. You can make the switch later in your career and still see the same effect.
This broad pattern, of shifting from exploring to exploiting, can be observed in the lives of late bloomers.
Now, this is not some sort of simple template for “how to be a late bloomer.” There is no ten-step plan. One major problem for late bloomers is that when you take the unconventional path—because you are unconventional—well, it isn’t as likely to work out. As Noah says,
In fact, this is bumbition’s inherent limitation. Sitting around waiting for the right opportunity to present itself is a highly uncertain, risky endeavor. There’s always the possibility that it won’t come until you’re old, or that it’ll come but you’ll fail to see it in time.
Someone who succeeds through bumbition can only be understood with the details of their life, not in some abstract formulation that can be turned into bullet points.
Late bloomers rarely take conventional career paths to success; if they did, perhaps they would not be late. Their progress is punctuated and disrupted, not smooth and steady. In this stage, their careers are often either dormant or patchwork, made of seemingly disparate parts. This might look listless, directionless or inefficient: rather than working towards a specific goal, late bloomers prepare for the unknown, the unexpected, the unstated. As with the explore mode, this stage has many influences, and what eventually triggers their transition to success might not be the most obvious or most expected thing. The idea that gets exploited is rarely the most popular, mostly highly cited or most recently discovered idea. It’s the most interesting.
This is why I spent the second half of Second Act looking at topics like networks, peer effects, luck, culture—diffuse and contingent aspects of life that cannot be put into easy formulas. It’s also why I included so many long biographical profiles. When it comes to late blooming, the devil is in the detail. You flourish as an individual, not a type.
What we will see is that weak ties – the phrase sociologists use to describe people we are only slightly acquainted with – are the people who can change our prospects, but only if they are influential. Good networking is not about knowing all the best people, but the few who can be credible and persuasive to the people we need to reach.
Personal transformation happens through cultural immersion, sampling the world and changing our surroundings. In new circumstances, gradually sampling our way into a new mode of thinking, living or working, we can change our opportunities, perhaps even change ourselves.
Moments of crisis have to be taken advantage of, not ignored or suffered through, whether that’s a personal tragedy, a moment of inspiration, or a gradual attrition of your will, caused dissatisfaction that culminates in desperation to change. Sometimes there are good reasons to have a midlife crisis, not to accept a slump but to use it as a pivot point.
Here is more of my writing about lat bloomers. Here is Noah’s piece about bumbition.

I'm reminded of the quote by Will Durant about Rousseau -- the ultimate Bumbitioner (rivalled only by Jesus and Hitler, his closest ancient and recent analogues):
"How did it come about that a man born poor, losing his mother at birth and soon deserted by his father, afflicted with a painful and humiliating disease, left to wander for twelve years among alien cities and conflicting faiths, repudiated by society and civilization, repudiating Voltaire, Diderot, the Encyclopedic, and the Age of Reason...
How did it come about that this man... had more effect upon posterity than any other writer or thinker of that eighteenth century?"