C.S. Lewis as a great reader
a podcast interview with me
Brown: Can you say more about his approach to reading and what you find distinctive about it?
Oliver: One thing that distinguished Lewis from a lot of people at the time was that he liked what we would call genre fiction. And obviously, he wrote genre fiction. And there’s the famous quote, I think, when, uh, he and Tolkien said to each other, “You know, all the other literati, they don’t like the sort of books we like. We’ll have to write our own books.” And what they meant by that was that they liked not just medieval stuff, Norse myths, and all that kind of thing, but they liked thrillers and adventures.
They didn’t necessarily love 19th-century realism or whatever. I mean, I think they were both actually big admirers of that work, they liked fairy tales. Lewis always called the Narnia books his fairy tales. And there are still sometimes attitudes about “These things are for children, they’re not for adults,” or there’s some kind of slightly distant snobbishness about the difference between genre fiction and other fiction.
It’s striking to me that there’s been this great integration of science fiction and fantasy with what is, quote unquote, called literary fiction, and that an awful lot of, however you want to call it, mainstream or literary fiction, has taken on all these elements and aspects of what in Lewis’s time were felt to be relatively separate things.3
So what he’s getting at there is that . . . and he has this good line about this. He says, you know, “Why has criticism not addressed this point? Why do some people like these books and others not? What’s actually going on there?” And he talks, I think very memorably, about someone he knew who was reading, I think, Cooper’s The Last of the Mohicans. And for Lewis, what was so important about a book like that—it’s not a book I’ve read—but he loved all the actual details of it, the actual specificity of the Native Americans and the landscape and the way that those things operated. Whereas the person he was talking to… you know, it could have been anything.
It could have been space, it could have been Native Americans, it could have been any other sort of genre. He just wanted the excitement of the story, the thrill of the chase, the chap to get whacked on the head, whatever it is. Lewis finds this, like, alien. This is appalling. How could he not love all those details?
And you see that in Narnia, right? You see that in the way he writes himself. So I think he is a great reader because he lets the book teach him how to read it. And he has what I would think of as a sort of an honest love of the thing itself. Lewis, he doesn’t really think that . . . I mean, he sometimes says things like this, but I’m not sure he’s very committed to these positions. He doesn’t think this book is going to improve you or make social commentary. He’s not interested in politics. He’s not interested in any of that stuff that’s come to sort of dominate literary discussion, and frankly, be just boring. He has an honest love of the thing itself.
We all, all of us who love Narnia, we all love it because Lucy walks through a wardrobe and meets a faun. We don’t love it because it’s this and because it’s that. We might also love those aspects of it. We might also admire the way it tells the Christian story. We might also admire the way it encapsulates a certain worldview, a certain period of history, whatever. But primarily, we have an honest love of the thing itself.
And that, I think, is what distinguishes Lewis as a great reader. That and the fact that he’s read everything. He remembers it. He knows how to relate it all. When he says, “It will lead you to everything else in the end,” in his case, that’s not an exaggeration. The rest of us, we’re not going to be led to everything else, but he had read an extraordinary amount.
That is from a recent podcast I recorded with Garrett Brown. We also talked about some of my own reading history and I read aloud from Lewis’s memoir and from Sohrab and Rustum. Garret also asked about reading poetry, Hamlet, reading aloud, and related topics.
Brown: Now, to shift to poetry, does poetry require more of us, more preparation before diving in? Or is it similar, just pick something and go for it?
Oliver: It depends what you mean by poetry. If you think that Ogden Nash counts as poetry, and you take a poem like “Candy is dandy, but liquor is quicker,” I don’t think that requires very much preparation. We can just enjoy that straight off the bat. I think that’s a great little poem.
Listen to the whole thing here—there is also a transcript. I enjoyed this conversation very much.

Discussion about this post