The two-cultures problem is still real
assorted grumbles and rants on recent topics
But it is happening. The world is changing. I’ve been following this technology for years, and for a long time I was cynical about it: I told myself that large language models would soon stop improving. Instead, their capabilities have only grown more prodigious. The only thing I believe now is that the years ahead of us are going to be strange and difficult. Our societies will change in response to this technology as much as they changed in response to the printing press, the locomotive, the internet and smartphones.
That is from Brunella Tipismana Urbano in The Point. It continues to strike me as weird and misguided that while AI is being developed at such a fast rate so much attention on literary Substack is given to a set of much more insular (and frankly merely political) questions.
Why aren’t more literary people interested in, for example, the way the Claude Constitution is written and the implications of that? Isn’t analyzing language what we are here for? Is it still plausible to ignore or resist AI when there is discussion of RSI taking off (whatever you happen to think of the “real situation”)? The question of AI consciousness is currently getting a lot of attention. What does criticism have to say?
The history of the two cultures debate—not just Snow (and Leavis’s nasty reply), but the whole tradition from at least Matthew Arnold onwards, including I.A. Richards, Aldous Huxley—often shows literary criticism at its least interesting or informed. T.R. Henn and C.S. Lewis excepted. Alas that it is still the case here today!
Normally, I try not to be grumpy about such matters, but reading Naomi’s very good piece about the brouhaha that surrounded her recently—a piece that was really quite gracious about people who were just plain condescending—made me feel once again the futility of such debates.
By no means do I think that everyone in the literary world ought to be writing about AI, or even writing about it very frequently. Some of the best literary writers on Substack never write about it. But while these changes in AI are happening, huge numbers of words are being dedicated to “who are the suitable people to be writing literary blogs”. Come on! Naomi of course has written some of her tales about AI and has made comments about it on Notes. Do that or write about some substantive literary topic, as Naomi also does! But don’t just mark everyone’s homework. (Naomi also lists several excellent scholarly writers on Substack.)
The real split on literary Substack, in my view, to the extent that there is a split, is not between amateurs and professionals (or however you wish to mark the scholarly and non-scholarly divide) but between those who have a primarily substantive interest in blogging and those who are primarily vexed by discourse. (One assumption in this debate has been that literary Substackers ignore certain areas of scholarship rather than hold legitimately different views. Nor was any consideration given to the idea that maybe some of us read that work and prefer to write about other things!) Some of the scholars writing in this discourse have been too concerned about responding to Liza Libes and justifying their own politics. No usage of scholarly tone and no amount of footnotes can change which side of that divide you are on.

More cultures than two - still lots of regular folks who are standing aside such disputes.
This reminds me to ask, what’s the scholarly consensus on the Oxford comma these days?