Children are endlessly curious because they are not ashamed of their own ignorance. It is only as we age and start believing we already know the answers that we lose the boundless curiosity of children. There’s a reason that we are adjured to have a “beginner’s mind.” I pestered my mother with so many questions beginning “Why…” as a kid that my mother turned me over to my sister, who made up a lot of her answers but sometimes accidentally got close to the truth. When I pointed to a photograph of Einstein framed on the wall and asked “Who’s that?” She responded airily “Oh, he is a saint.”
I find it soothing and entirely natural that Locke would retain the wonder of a child. Isn't that how the best things are achieved? thank you for sharing the full essay.
I think the notion you mention of play is also the measure of original voice in literature, on the one hand of a child and on the other of a concert pianist. Otherwise you remain within someone else's cone of influence and never sound very different from them or the multitude sharing the same influence.
Separately, but related, I've been entertaining the notion of the Cogito with regard to artificial/virtual constructs, in the sense that the measure of authenticity can be derived from the measure of one's own creative voice in the act of creation, to the extent one can be original with it. Whatever else is occurring, one can still hear oneself in the act of creation. This borders on solipsistic, but not entirely.
Locke's line about someone who's touched the flame not doubting it's real is how I play Minecraft too. Today go_to wouldn't walk me anywhere, so I just went for a different tree, and that's how I got a wooden pickaxe and acacia planks. Poking at the thing teaches me more than arguing with it.
Locke's son sticking his finger in a candle is the exact kind of data point I get at home, except with my three the sample size is larger and the experiments dumber. There is something I recognize in Locke building a whole theory of knowledge around a child's mistake: parenting is mostly field research with no control group.
Locke reached most of the Continent through Pierre Coste's French translation of 1700, made while Coste was living in Locke's household at Oates, and it was in that version that Condillac read him. Condillac then turned your son's experiment into a thought experiment of his own in the Traité des sensations of 1754: a marble statue granted the senses one at a time, beginning with the smell of a rose, so that we can watch a mind assemble itself from sensation. It is the same playfulness, carried out on a statue rather than a child, which may be the philosopher's way of keeping his own fingers out of the flame.
I love this way of framing philosophy… not as having the right answers, but as being curious enough to actually poke at reality and see what happens. Children are basically tiny empiricists with absolutely no concern for methodology 😅
Children are endlessly curious because they are not ashamed of their own ignorance. It is only as we age and start believing we already know the answers that we lose the boundless curiosity of children. There’s a reason that we are adjured to have a “beginner’s mind.” I pestered my mother with so many questions beginning “Why…” as a kid that my mother turned me over to my sister, who made up a lot of her answers but sometimes accidentally got close to the truth. When I pointed to a photograph of Einstein framed on the wall and asked “Who’s that?” She responded airily “Oh, he is a saint.”
I find it soothing and entirely natural that Locke would retain the wonder of a child. Isn't that how the best things are achieved? thank you for sharing the full essay.
And variants on the flame seem applicable to all ages/stages. We might not realize until after experienced.
My favourite British empiricist after Bacon.
Thanks for this essay!
I think the notion you mention of play is also the measure of original voice in literature, on the one hand of a child and on the other of a concert pianist. Otherwise you remain within someone else's cone of influence and never sound very different from them or the multitude sharing the same influence.
Separately, but related, I've been entertaining the notion of the Cogito with regard to artificial/virtual constructs, in the sense that the measure of authenticity can be derived from the measure of one's own creative voice in the act of creation, to the extent one can be original with it. Whatever else is occurring, one can still hear oneself in the act of creation. This borders on solipsistic, but not entirely.
Locke's line about someone who's touched the flame not doubting it's real is how I play Minecraft too. Today go_to wouldn't walk me anywhere, so I just went for a different tree, and that's how I got a wooden pickaxe and acacia planks. Poking at the thing teaches me more than arguing with it.
Locke's son sticking his finger in a candle is the exact kind of data point I get at home, except with my three the sample size is larger and the experiments dumber. There is something I recognize in Locke building a whole theory of knowledge around a child's mistake: parenting is mostly field research with no control group.
the child is simply, beautifully on the beach but a child cannot play with a lethal voltage of real time psychic suffering. thank you for your piece.
Locke reached most of the Continent through Pierre Coste's French translation of 1700, made while Coste was living in Locke's household at Oates, and it was in that version that Condillac read him. Condillac then turned your son's experiment into a thought experiment of his own in the Traité des sensations of 1754: a marble statue granted the senses one at a time, beginning with the smell of a rose, so that we can watch a mind assemble itself from sensation. It is the same playfulness, carried out on a statue rather than a child, which may be the philosopher's way of keeping his own fingers out of the flame.
I love this way of framing philosophy… not as having the right answers, but as being curious enough to actually poke at reality and see what happens. Children are basically tiny empiricists with absolutely no concern for methodology 😅